REGISTER
Why Japan Doesn't Vaccinate for Rabies, Unlike China with Over 10 Million Annual Inoculations?
Prevention of rabies in humans begins with the control of canine rabies, and by keeping canine immunization rates above 70%, it is sufficient to block the chain of rabies transmission between dogs.

As the weather gets hotter and hotter, animals are becoming more aggressive. According to media reports, since July 12-19, more than 1,300 patients have been seen in the canine injury clinic of Ningbo Huaci Hospital in one week, of which cat injuries accounted for 55% and canine injuries accounted for 42.7%.


Recently, the CDC in many places also issued an article through the official Wechat platform, reminding that summer is the high incidence of rabies, and that rabies vaccination is required after rabies exposure. According to the statutory infectious disease report released by the CDC, from January to May, China has reported 47 cases of infectious diseases and 37 deaths.


The Status of Rabies Prevention and Control in China disclosed that China is the world's largest market for human rabies vaccine, with annual rabies vaccine use of about 12-15 million doses and annual direct costs of about 3.5-5 billion yuan. It was evaluated by the media as, “The price paid is the world's first vaccine input, but the effect of epidemic prevention is the world's second-last.”


Unlike in China, where a large number of people go for rabies vaccination every year, almost very few people go for rabies vaccination in Japan, where rabies vaccination is mainly given to animals. To date, Japan has maintained a rabies-free reporting status for 65 years, and is known as one of the few countries in Asia to have eliminated dog-mediated rabies transmission.


Rabies is an ancient and dreaded disease with written and photographic records dating back more than 4,000 years. According to information on the World Health Organization's official website, rabies exists in more than 150 countries and territories worldwide and causes tens of thousands of deaths each year, mainly in Asia and Africa, with 40% of the dead being children under the age of 15. Dogs are the leading cause of human rabies deaths, leading to 99% of human rabies transmission.


Japan's successful experience is not complicated and can be summarized as follows: registration of dogs, annual rabies vaccination, surveillance, and strict quarantine of imported animals. Vaccination of dogs is also recommended and considered by the World Health Organization to be the most cost-effective method of preventing rabies in humans, as it interrupts transmission at the source and reduces the need for post-exposure prophylaxis in humans.


As early as 1896 and 1897, Japan introduced the Animal Disease Control Law and the Infectious Disease Control Law and published the first rabies statistics, with a total of 71 cases of canine rabies detected.The first human rabies cases were reported in 1912, a year in which a total of 83 human rabies cases and 696 canine cases were reported in Japan. These two statistics peaked in 1924, when over 3,000 canine and 235 human rabies deaths were reported.


Due to the rapid increase of rabies in animals, Japan enacted the Livestock Infectious Disease Control Law in 1922, which allowed the killing of all rabies-infected livestock and the control of stray dogs. In the following decades, the number of human and canine rabies cases in Japan declined rapidly.


Further improvements in rabies prevention and control in Japan came with the enactment of two other laws - the Rabies Prevention Law of 1950 and the New Livestock Infectious Disease Control Law of 1951 - particularly the former, which introduced mandatory pet owner compliance with pet dog registration and annual anti-rabies vaccinations, as well as mandatory management of stray dogs by local governments. In addition, in terms of quarantine for the import and export of animals, the two laws require dogs, cats, foxes, raccoons, and skunks to be subject to import quarantine; for example, the importation of a dog or a cat usually requires eight steps, with a process time of 210 days or more.


The implementation of the law was so effective that Japan achieved zero local cases of human rabies in 1956 and zero domestic animal rabies (domestic cats) in 1957.


For more than 60 years since then, Japan has also been strengthening “animal control”. For example, in 1999, the Infectious Disease Control Act was enacted to include rabies as a Category 4 infectious disease, meaning that doctors who diagnose rabies patients must immediately report all cases to the governor of the state in which they reside; in order to respond to potential rabies outbreaks in the community, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare issued the “Guidelines for Responding to Rabies Outbreaks in Japan” in 2001 and the “2013 Rabies Response Guidelines” in 2013, which are used for responding to rabies in dogs found in Japan. “ in 2013 and the “2013 Rabies Response Guidelines” for risk management of rabid dogs found in Japan. Currently, April to June is designated as “Rabies Vaccination Month” in Japan to encourage all pet owners to complete their pets' annual vaccinations.


Unlike in China, where rabies has been a taboo subject for more than half a century, in Japan rabies awareness is extremely low, and it has even become a “forgotten disease”. Instead, the issue of how to raise and maintain awareness of rabies in Japan has become a matter of concern.


This problem has had some serious consequences, such as the fact that few people in Japan are vaccinated before traveling because they are unaware of the worldwide prevalence of rabies. Reasons for this include the fact that the human rabies vaccine is usually only available at clinics involved in travel, many of which are located in large cities. The vaccine is also expensive, costing 15,000-20,000 yen ($130-174 USD) per shot, and three vaccinations must be given to acquire antibodies. This led to the deaths of four people from dog bites while traveling abroad in 1957, after rabies was eliminated in Japan.


WHO has also pointed out that the prevention of rabies in humans begins with the control of canine rabies, and that as long as the immunization rate of dogs is kept above 70%, it is sufficient to block the chain of rabies transmission among dogs.


In 2015, WHO set a global goal of “eliminating canine-mediated rabies by 2030”. Today, more than 30 countries and regions around the world have already eliminated rabies transmitted from dogs to humans, and strengthening canine immunization is one of the most important measures.


The country has not yet achieved the goal of eliminating rabies. According to data from the National Bureau of Disease Control and Prevention, the number of human rabies cases in China has achieved 16 consecutive years of decline, but 127 people will still die of rabies in 2023.


Just as worrisome as the high incidence rate is China's huge expenditure on human rabies vaccine. In China, the current initiatives to prevent and control rabies are still mainly the injection of human vaccines, and the rate of canine immunization is not high.2023 Liu Qing, deputy director of the Department of Infectious Disease Prevention and Control of the National Bureau of Disease Control and Prevention, also pointed out that China's current rabies prevention and control still has shortcomings in the area of prevention and control at the source.


Reference:

[1]Koji Kanda et al., Maintenance of Rabies-free Status in Japan for 65 Years and Application of Lessons Learned to Other Countries Working Towards Zero Human Deaths, Chapter 19, In a eBook on Rabies ©CAB International 2023. One Health for Dog-mediated Rabies Elimination in Asia: A Collection of Local Experiences,(eds V. Slack et al.),https://doi.org/10.1079/9781800622975.0019.

[2]南都健闻.去年我国16省狂犬病发病134例 专家呼吁加强动物免疫.https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/xdvC13E7HfQLeXsxAI9GYQ

[3]疫苗中国.从全球狂犬病负担看我国狂犬病防控.https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/_YAt9jPexipQdMSL48oPjA

0
0
Loading