After undergoing 75 brain MRI scans on herself, American neuroscientist Carina Heller has been called "the woman with the most brain scans in the scientific community" by Nature.为
To study the effects of birth control on women's brains, Heller conducted an experiment on herself, using MRI to record changes in brain morphology and functional areas during her menstrual cycle, and found that taking short-acting oral contraceptives may cause changes in women's brains.
Recently, the top international scientific journal Nature published an article introducing this research. Nature believes that Heller's findings help to explore the complex relationship between sex hormones and women's brains, providing more data for women to use birth control and guiding women to choose the most suitable contraceptive plan for themselves.
After reading the report in Nature, Professor Cheng Linan, the director of the Sixth Committee of the Family Planning Branch of the Chinese Medical Association, told "Medical World" that this is an individual study. Although the researcher observed changes in her own brain, "how this is related to changes in women's emotional functions and other changes needs further exploration."
Neuroscientist Carina Heller filled the gap in women's health research with her own brain MRI results. Image source/Nature
Birth control pills may cause changes in women's brains
Heller has studied at several prestigious universities in Europe and America, with expertise covering psychology, philosophy, neuroscience, and other fields.
She has focused on analyzing changes in white matter and gray matter in patients with DiGeorge syndrome, a chromosomal disease that increases the risk of schizophrenia in adulthood. She has also delved into the causes of "brain fog" after acute COVID-19 infection.
Around 2020, Heller became interested in the relationship between birth control and women's brains. At that time, neuroscientist Laura Pritschet, to understand the impact of hormonal fluctuations on the brain, performed a brain MRI on herself every 24 hours for 30 days, and in a derivative project, continuously scanned her husband's brain.
Pritsch found that high levels of estrogen would reshape the hippocampus and reorganize the connections between different brain regions. For example, the "default mode network" related to daydreaming, memory, and other cognitive functions may be affected. The effect of progesterone is just the opposite.
"Many brain and neurological studies are limited by cost and can only perform 1-2 brain MRI scans on 10-30 subjects. This cannot explain the daily changes in brain morphology and connectivity," Nature wrote. "Intensive sampling" like Pritschet's can observe dynamic and fine changes in individuals.
Heller was inspired. After consulting with her team, she completed the required number of brain MRI scans in three stages within one year: during natural menstruation, after using oral contraceptives for 3 months, and after stopping the medication for 3 months.
According to this calculation, Heller needs to scan her brain 25 times in 5 weeks for each stage.
Every scanning day, at 7:30 in the morning, she would get into the MRI device and lie motionless for 1.5 hours. At 9 o'clock, she would draw blood and then fill out the daily mood survey questionnaire.
"Just like drinking coffee or meditating, MRI scans almost became my morning routine," Heller recalls.
At the annual meeting of the American Society for Neuroscience held in early October 2024, Heller was invited to report on this single-arm trial.
The study results showed that under natural menstruation, Heller's brain volume and connections between different brain regions showed rhythmic changes. For example, after the ovaries release eggs, the volume of the bilateral hippocampus in the brain would increase.
After taking birth control pills, this rhythmic change seemed to "weaken." In other words, while taking the medication, Heller's body and brain seemed to be detached from the influence of natural menstrual cycle hormonal fluctuations. Once the medication is stopped, the brain changes gradually return to normal.
In addition, based on the results of the mood questionnaire, Heller found that during the normal menstrual cycle, an increase in hippocampal volume can be observed with positive emotions. On the other hand, an increase in estrogen levels related to birth control pills is associated with negative emotions such as sadness and irritability.
July 25, 2023, Heller at the 2023 Annual Meeting of the Organization for Human Brain Mapping. Image source/HellerCarina@X
Why focus on "birth control reshaping the brain"?
Professor Cheng Linan told "Medical World" that more than ten years ago, when she visited the United States for academic purposes, she heard that someone was studying the impact of birth control on the brain. "There are all kinds of directions, mainly to eliminate people's misunderstandings about oral contraceptives."
Since the first drug was approved in the United States in 1960, oral contraceptives have rapidly become popular, and to date, more than 150 million women of childbearing age have used them, "making it one of the most commonly used drugs in the world," as described by Nature.
The first users of the drug were women from the "30s" and "40s" in developed countries. The medical community has verified the safety of birth control pills from them. For example, long-term and reasonable use does not increase the overall risk of cancer, does not lead to infertility, and has other health benefits, including treating acne, relieving menstrual pain, and treating migraines...
The academic community is also particularly concerned about the association between birth control pills and the brain, on the one hand, because its users are healthy people, and the requirements for safety are higher. On the other hand, Professor Cheng Linan introduced, "It has a rare side effect related to the brain, which is depression, and it can naturally improve after stopping use."
As early as the 1970s, studies observed that birth control pills may be related to women's mental and psychological health. The theoretical basis is that short-acting contraceptives contain different proportions of estrogen and progestin, which may bind to receptors in different areas of the brain, inhibit the production of endogenous hormones in the body, cause the menstrual cycle to stop, and prevent ovulation.
To achieve contraceptive effects, unlike the natural menstrual cycle, short-acting contraceptives keep women's hormone levels in a state similar to pregnancy, and some emotional issues common during pregnancy, such as anxiety and sentimentality, also appear. Based on these findings, contraceptives have been continuously iterated. Recent studies have shown that new types of contraceptives may have less impact on emotions.
However, it is worth noting that the medical community is still uncertain about a necessary link between contraceptives and emotional changes, and a large number of studies have also failed to draw a consistent association. It was not until brain imaging was extensively applied to brain research that the changes in anatomical structures became apparent, and the deadlock seemed to be broken.
In 2010, the journal Brain Research published an article stating that after some women took contraceptives, the gray matter in the brain responsible for social interaction and memory expanded, possibly becoming smarter.
Since then, scholars from Europe and America have successively found that contraceptives may affect different brain areas. Some female subjects showed weakened stress responses; some had their ability to regulate negative emotions suppressed; and some people's hypothalamus seemed to shrink, making them more prone to depression and irritability.
Kathryn Lenz, a behavioral neuroscientist at the Columbus branch of Ohio State University, believes that many women start using contraceptives during adolescence, which is a sensitive period for brain development and maturation. Therefore, studying the impact of contraceptives on the brain is of great significance.
Next, Heller hopes to recruit a woman with endometriosis to conduct intensive sampling research to explore whether hormonal fluctuations are a cause of the disease.
In addition, she plans to expand the research sample of brain scans by recruiting a group of women with various health conditions to find individual differences and reveal why some women have adverse reactions after using contraceptives, while others do not. The relevant findings will help drug development, adverse reaction intervention, etc., and assist women who experience emotional fluctuations while taking contraceptives.
"Heller's research is still relatively 'coarse' and belongs to individual observation. It only sees changes in brain morphology and is not clear how this affects behavioral changes," Professor Cheng Linan told "Medical World." China also needs to conduct more research on short-acting contraceptives, but our main focus should be on the side effects of oral contraceptives.
"There is too much misleading information now. Some people regard induced abortion as contraception, which causes far more harm to women than the side effects of oral contraceptives," Professor Cheng Linan warned.
References:
1.How does the brain react to birth control? A researcher scanned herself 75 times to find out. Nature. doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-03368-4
2.Carina Heller, et al. Hippocampal volume and affect in response to fluctuating estrogens in menstrual cycle irregularity: a longitudinal single-subject study. npj women's health. doi.org/10.1038/s44294-024-00023-1
3.Jesse M Lacasse, et al. Beyond Birth Control: The Neuroscience of Hormonal Contraceptives. J Neurosci. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1235-24.2024.
4.Belinda Pletzer, et al. Menstrual cycle and hormonal contraceptive use modulate human brain structure. Brain Res. doi: 10.1016/j.brainres.2010.06.019.
5.Alexandra Brouillard, et al. Morphologic alterations of the fear circuitry: the role of sex hormones and oral contraceptives. Front. Endocrinol. doi.org/10.3389/fendo.2023.1228504