REGISTER
Global First: Patient Dies After Hospital Hit by Cyberattack

A cyberattack targeting the healthcare system not only severely disrupted the operations of numerous hospitals but also led to the death of a patient due to delayed treatment. The UK’s National Health Service (NHS) recently reported the incident.

According to the NHS, this is the world’s first confirmed case of a patient’s death directly caused by a cybersecurity incident, as acknowledged by a healthcare institution. In addition, 170 patients were harmed to varying degrees, over ten thousand outpatient appointments were affected, and 1,710 elective surgeries were cancelled or postponed.

Experts stated that this incident highlights the severe cybersecurity threats facing the healthcare industry. Authorities must continue to strengthen protective measures to safeguard medical operations and patients’ rights.

Cyberattack Brings Hospitals to a Halt

The tragedy occurred in June 2024.An NHS investigation revealed that a hacker group launched a cyberattack on Synnovis, a third-party pathology services provider that collaborates with the NHS to deliver blood testing and other medical services.

Earlier in March, the same group claimed responsibility for attacks on a cancer clinic in Japan and an obstetrics and gynecology hospital in the United States. A spokesperson for the group openly declared they felt “zero remorse.”According to disclosed information, the hackers employed a double-extortion strategy: they first encrypted and stole internal Synnovis files, then threatened to leak sensitive data. These actions caused the collapse of Synnovis’s information systems, making it impossible to transmit critical medical data in a timely manner.

Experts from the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) in the UK noted that today’s healthcare systems heavily depend on real-time data transmission, which magnifies the negative effects of cyberattacks.Multiple hospitals, including university teaching hospitals, were impacted during the incident. The healthcare system in southeast London was temporarily paralyzed, and many general practitioner clinics were unable to book blood tests for their patients.

Some medical institutions even came close to suspending non-urgent blood test requests due to the attack. Reportedly, it took more than three weeks on average for the affected institutions to fully restore normal medical operations.More seriously, one patient’s follow-up treatment was interrupted because blood test results were not returned in time. The patient later died. Medical experts identified this delay as the direct cause of death.

In addition, the affected healthcare institutions recorded two cases of severe harm, eleven moderate injuries, and 120 minor injuries. Due to patient privacy concerns, further details have not been disclosed.According to media reports, the hackers attempted to extort $50 million in ransom from Synnovis in exchange for the stolen data.

After their demand was refused, the stolen data was published on the dark web. The data included patient names, birthdates, NHS numbers, and personal contact details. Some information involved diagnoses related to sexually transmitted diseases and cancer.

The intelligence platform operated by cybersecurity company Recorded Future recently disclosed that data from approximately 900,000 patients was leaked. Even a year after the incident, many affected patients still have no idea their sensitive medical data is being widely circulated online.

Cyberattacks on Medical Information Systems Becoming More Common

“The threat cyberattacks pose to patient safety has existed for a long time. Now, we finally have painful evidence,” said Dr. Saif Abed, a former NHS physician and an expert in cybersecurity and public health, in a media interview.

On November 8, 2024, the United Nations Security Council held a special meeting to address ransomware and other cyberattacks targeting healthcare systems.

World Health Organization Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus and others emphasized that such incidents involve not only security and confidentiality but also life-and-death matters, posing potential threats to international security.“Ransomware and other cyberattacks not only cause chaos and economic loss but also erode public trust in the healthcare systems they rely on — and can even lead to patient injury or death,” said Tedros.

Ascension, the third-largest healthcare provider in the United States, shared its own experience with Security Council members. Ascension is a nonprofit Catholic healthcare system that provides care to over six million Americans annually, particularly the poor and vulnerable.On May 8, 2024, the company fell victim to a ransomware attack, which encrypted thousands of system files and rendered them inoperable. In response, Ascension’s medical teams immediately initiated emergency shutdown protocols and switched to using paper records.

By June 14 — 37 days after the attack — Ascension finally restored access to its information systems. During the outage, the medical team reportedly used so much paper that if stacked, it would be over 1,600 meters tall.According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, from early 2024 to November, a total of 386 healthcare-related cyberattacks were reported in the United States. Notably, cyberattacks targeting the healthcare industry are increasing in both scale and frequency.

The Ponemon Institute, an independent organization focusing on privacy, data protection, and cybersecurity policy research, found that nearly 90% of healthcare organizations have experienced data breaches. A portion of these organizations also had patient records compromised.The institute attributes the rising number of attacks to low vigilance among healthcare organizations, insufficient investment in IT security (including manpower, funding, and technology), and the high value of healthcare data compared to other industries.

According to information presented to the Security Council, a global survey completed in 2021 showed that over one-third of healthcare institutions surveyed experienced at least one ransomware attack in the preceding year. Even among those who paid the ransom, 31% were still unable to regain access to their encrypted data.

However, publicly disclosed reports of patient harm due to cyberattacks remain rare. In 2019, a hospital in Alabama, USA, experienced a system failure due to a hacking incident. A mother reported that doctors were unable to read fetal monitoring results in time, missing the window to intervene, which resulted in the death of her newborn. The case was ultimately settled privately.

RUSI analysts believe this is likely due to the difficulty in definitively linking cyberattacks to medical safety events.The BBC reported that researchers at the University of Minnesota School of Public Health previously claimed that between 2016 and 2021, ransomware attacks may have caused the deaths of 42 to 67 Medicare patients in the U.S. However, these findings have yet to be published in a peer-reviewed journal, and some scholars have questioned the statistical significance of the conclusions.

In its public statements, the NHS has warned that, over the past year, other NHS trusts and medical facilities — including top children’s hospitals and cancer treatment centers — have also become targets of cyberattacks.

1
1
Loading